Why Project Managers Fail 9 Times Out of 10
How to identify and overcome blind spots in project management.
đ Hey, Kyle here! Welcome to The Influential Project Manager, a weekly newsletter covering the essentials of successful project leadership.
Todayâs Overview:
9 out of 10 major construction projects run over schedule due to blind spots in planning, execution, and decision-making.
Complexity, cognitive biases, and decision-making distance create hidden risks that derail projects, waste resources, and damage trust.
We can address our blind spots with a three-part strategy: learn from history, leverage AI-powered tools, and master the fundamentals of planning, communication, and leadership. This guide will show you how to tackle blind spots head-on and deliver projects with confidence and consistency.
đď¸ Todayâs newsletter is brought to you by Foresight!
AI-Enabled Construction Project Management.
Foresightâs construction project management platform helps owners and contractors deliver major projects on-time by automatically identifying priorities, risks, and action plans in Primavera P6 or Microsoft Project schedules. We place the schedule at the heart of project execution, enabling project managers, controllers and schedulers to make data-driven decisions.
Leveraging AI, machine learning, and natural language processing, Foresight unleashes predictive insights about delay risks and work prioritization. Our secure, scalable, and user-friendly platform revolutionizes your planning and execution by creating proactive âlook-aheadâ action plans, igniting dynamic collaboration, staying ahead of risks, learning from past projects, and enhancing schedule visibility/reporting.
đ§ Why Project Managers Fail 9 Times Out of 10
Filed under: Project Management
What if you could see the future of your project with perfect clarity?
Imagine playing poker with full knowledge of everyoneâs cards. you'd never make a wrong move.
While perfect foresight remains impossible, understanding and addressing our blind spots might be the next best thing. Blind spotsâthe gaps in what we see and understandâare the source of all poor decisions.
A recent Oxford study examining 432 major construction projects totaling over $759 billion revealed a sobering reality: 90% of projects exceed budgets and miss deadlines, with average cost overruns reaching 40% and schedule delays hitting 34%. Most troubling, one in ten projects becomes a catastrophic "black swan" event that threatens organizational survival.
These statistics represent billions in wasted resources, countless missed opportunities, and immeasurable damage to organizational relationships and reputations. And yet, despite decades of advancements in project management tools and methodologies, these issues persist.
Why? The answer lies in understanding our blind spots. In life and business, the person with the fewest blind spots wins.
The Three Critical Blind Spots
1. The Complexity Trap
The first major blind spot comes from pure complexity. Modern projects have reached a level of complexity that exceeds human cognitive capacity.
Research shows the human brain can effectively track only five to seven pieces of information simultaneously. But a project manager must monitor hundreds of critical path dependencies, track numerous risks, and coordinate multiple stakeholder needs â all while keeping the schedule on track.
This cognitive overload leads to predictable failures:
Critical dependencies slip through despite regular reviews
Resource conflicts emerge unexpectedly
Warning signs get lost in the flood of project data
Integration issues surface late, when they're costliest to fix
2. Cognitive Biases
Itâs tempting to think that projects fail because the world throws surprises at us: price and scope changes, accidents, weather, new management, etc. But this is shallow thinking.
Harsh truth: your biggest risk is you. Our brains come pre-wired with biases that distort decision-making. Four are particularly dangerous for project managers:
Optimism Bias: The tendency to underestimate challenges and overestimate our ability to overcome them. The Sydney Opera House didn't fail because its architect lacked skill â it failed because of blind optimism about timelines and costs.
Overconfidence Bias: Excessive certainty in our predictions and failure to recognize uncertainty. This leads to inadequate contingency planning and brittle project structures that break under pressure.
Uniqueness Bias: The belief that our project is more singular than it actually is, leading us to ignore valuable lessons from similar past projects.
The Planning Fallacy: The systematic tendency to underestimate time, costs, and risks while overestimating benefits and opportunities. This creates project plans that look good on paper but crumble in reality.
3. The Distance Problem
The third blind spot arises from physical and organizational distance between decision-makers and execution teams. The further removed leaders are from the ground-level realities, the harder it is to make sound decisions. This manifests as:
Delayed problem awareness due to slow information flow
Misaligned priorities between planners and field teams
Failure to adjust plans based on real-time conditions
Large projects often remove us from the direct consequences of our decisions. When we make decisions that other people carry out, we are one or more levels removed from their consequences and may not immediately be able to update our understanding.
How to Overcome Your Blind Spots
Overcoming these blind spots requires a three-pronged approach that combines timeless principles with cutting-edge technology. Here's what works:
1. Learn from History
Your project isnât unique, and thinking otherwise is a recipe for chaos. Believing your project is special blinds you to patterns and lessons from the past.
One powerful solution is through systematic comparison with past projects - what researchers call reference class forecasting. This anchors your planning in historical reality rather than wishful thinking.
This involves:
Studying previous projects and phases to identify patterns and failure points.
Establish parameters:
Schedule & budget
Roadblocks & constraints
Overall variance in each of the above
Deep dive into the data of each project.
Establishing probability distributions for risks and opportunities.
Using this data to create more accurate schedules and budgets.
When done right, this structured approach transforms the unknown into something manageable, so you can build more realistic commitments.
2. Leverage Smart Technology
AI wonât replace project managersâbut project managers who use AI will outpace those who donât. The opportunity starts with the most important document on any project: the schedule.
Traditional Critical Path Method (CPM) scheduling has serious limitations:
Binary thinking: It treats all critical tasks equally, offering no sense of priority between them.
Critical path congestion: When 60-80% of activities are labeled âcritical,â prioritization becomes meaningless.
Blind spots in non-critical tasks: Non-critical tasks can easily become critical, but CPM doesnât highlight them until itâs too late.
Manipulation and bias: Difficult to spot issues, easy to bury problems. Constraints and manual inputs can distort priorities, making the process subjective.
Erratic durations and complex relationships add complexity.
Fluctuating resource requirements cause inefficiencies for everyone involved.
Advanced project management platforms powered by artificial intelligence can help tackle complexity by processing massive amounts of data and identifying critical patterns.
The Foresight AI Engine, for example, addresses these limitations by:
âď¸ Providing data-driven prioritization that goes beyond the critical path.
âď¸ Spotting patterns and risks early, even in non-critical tasks.
âď¸ Delivering real-time insights across all activities, not just the critical path.
âď¸ Offering transparent, bias-resistant analysis to ensure objectivity.
The real power comes from combining AI capabilities with human judgment. Technology should handle data complexity and pattern recognition, freeing project managers to focus on leadership, strategy, and relationship building.
3. Master the Fundamentals
While new tools are essential, the best project managers never lose sight of the basics. Blind spots shrink when you build a strong foundation:
Sound Planning Principles: Base estimates on historical data rather than optimism. Build realistic contingencies into your budgets and schedules. Treat the schedule as your primary coordination tool. Most importantly, maintain the discipline to follow these principles even under pressure. The power is in the planning, the plan.
Clear Communication: Create open channels between field teams, management, and stakeholders. Make it safe for team members to raise concerns early. Make sure stakeholders understand not just what is happening, but why. Focus on holding remarkable meetings on identifying and addressing potential issues, not just reporting progress.
Team Confidence: Develop a culture of problem-solving. Confidence comes from knowing that solutions exist and you have the skills to find them. Build strong working relationships so your team can collaborate effectively in high-pressure situations.
Trust and Psychological Safety: Encourage an environment where collective success matters more than individual achievement. Ensure your team feels comfortable addressing blind spots and proposing solutions without fear of blame.
These fundamentals amplify the impact of both historical learning and AI tools. Without them, even the best systems will fail to deliver results.
The Path Forward
You can't plan for everything, but you can prepare for anything.
Success in modern project management isn't about being a genius â it's about having the humility to recognize our limitations and the wisdom to build systems that help us overcome them.
For organizations ready to address their blind spots, several concrete steps can help:
Review current practices to identify potential blind spots
Build reference classes from historical project data
Implement systems for early problem identification
Explore how advanced technology can augment existing capabilities
The future belongs to organizations that effectively combine human expertise with advanced capabilities to overcome their blind spots. Those who succeed will find themselves not just delivering projects more reliably, but building sustainable competitive advantage in an increasingly complex world.
Remember: In project management, as in life, the person with the fewest blind spots wins. Make sure that person is you.
đ¤ How Foresight Can Help
Foresight leverages Nobel-prize winning research in psychology and economics to create the worldâs first platform that continually learns to support you. Itâs designed to help you overcome your blind spots.
The platform uses your existing schedule data to deliver insights and workflow automations that really matter. The result? Less time spent on reporting, fewer unforeseen risks, and up to a 10% reduction in project duration.
Want to see how Foresight can transform your projects? Book a demo today.
Until next week,
Kyle Nitchen
Whenever you're ready, there are 5 ways I can help you:
Get my first book! No Bullsh*t Project: A Project Managerâs Guide to Successful Project Leadership
Upgrade your scheduling software. Experience the future planning system for construction and real estate development. iPM subscribers can enjoy a 15% discount on first year license.
Get my full toolbox (free). Access 30+ software and hardware tools I'm using today.
Learn Takt Planning. Elevate your skills as a scheduler, planner, and lean builder with the Takt Planning & Control online course. Use code "Influentialpmtakt" for 30% off.
Advertise in my newsletter. Put your brand in front of 5,600+ construction project managers, leaders, and execs. (Booked out 8 weeks)